Franklin D. Roosevelt: Stamp Collector

Franklin D. Roosevelt was a collector of all sorts of stuff from boyhood.

The Budding Philatelist

Franklin D. Roosevelt (1882-1945) was the only child of a middle-aged father and his much younger second wife. It had been extremely difficult for Sara Delano Roosevelt, and the doctors advised the couple that more children would not be forthcoming. Sara plowed all her maternal energies into raising her son. Despite the Roosevelt (and Delano) wealth and prominence, the new mother insisted on performing most of the child-rearing tasks rather than delegate to the nurses and nannies popular with their upper crust social set.

FDR and parents

As an only child, the young boy was raised in an “adult” environment with very few available children of his own age to play with regularly. His education was via tutors. His vacations were accompanying his parents abroad. He learned early on to amuse himself – by himself.

By the time he was seven or eight, he had developed an interest it stamp collecting – a popular hobby then and even now. Philatelist is the “official” or “fancy” term they use for the pastime. FDR acquired the proper albums and magnifying glass, scissors and paste supplies, and whatever “instructional” materials were available. Visits to the local post office were frequent. 

It is said, (generally by himself) that he learned geography primarily from his stamp collection. By the time he was a lad, circa 1890, sending and receiving mail all over the world required a stamp. Each time FDR discovered a new stamp from a new part of the world, he eagerly checked the encyclopedia and atlas to learn as much as he could about the particular nation. 

At his death, he had a collection of about 1 million stamps, but according to stamp collecting experts, FDR’s collection was not particularly exotic or rare. He seldom sought hard-to-find or mint-imperfect additions for his hobby. He was content to occupy himself with generally available products, and found his pleasure in being a happy hobbyist. He loved learning about where they came from and the people/events they commemorated – rather than the details of the stamp process itself.

The Polio Hobby

Roosevelt was nearly 40 when he contracted infantile paralysis, better known as polio. Despite the best available care and treatment, the disease took a huge toll on his health. He would never walk again without heavy braces and similar aids. His self-designed wheelchair was always nearby. 

FDR’s stamp collection was always nearby.

Once the acute throes of pain and infirmity had abated, the former Assistant Secretary of the Navy and losing Vice Presidential candidate of 1920 needed to find other outlets for his energies. His health came first, of course. He spent the better part of the 1920s on long therapeutic trips to warm climates with warm waters. Swimming was considered the most successful treatment for polio victims. It would be a part of his regular routine for the rest of his life. As a side benefit (since he never regained the use of his legs) the upper part of his body was considerably strengthened. 

Collecting stamps is a pastime that one can do sitting at a desk. And even when FDR was “living” on a boat, or in a cottage in Warm Springs, GA, stamp albums and related “equipment” was packed along with his clothing and books. He found it restful. Some believe that he found time everyday to “play with his stamps.”

By the time he reactivated himself in politics and became the Governor of New York, stamp collecting had become an extremely popular hobby. King George V of Great Britain was known to be an avid collector, albeit of the more exotic ephemera. His son, who later became King George VI, was also a stamp collector. And when FDR became US President, its popularity reached its height. 

George V
George VI

The Postmaster General made sure the President received the latest stamp issues, and FDR personally sketched out new ideas for stamps.

The Philatelists were happy to endorse him!

The Presidential Philatelist

Once WWII started in Europe, Roosevelt’s stamp collection played a dual role. Naturally, the old hobby relaxed him, and his closest aides understood its importance in channeling his thought processes. Then again, his interest and knowledge of geography became even more acute. 

Historian Paul Boller tells a story that in 1940, FDR was cruising on the Presidential Yacht and learned of an Allied air raid bombing of a small Mediterranean island called Taranto. His aides, including some military brass, had never heard of the place. But Roosevelt, having stamps from that island, and having checked the atlas and reference books, knew exactly where it was. He also knew the distance between Taranto and Malta and Gibraltar, ergo why it was an important strategic location.

After the Japanese Attack on Pearl Harbor, tiny obscure islands in the Pacific Ocean were in all the headlines. He had obtained stamps from many of those places years earlier, and the knowledge of them became a great benefit, especially when he talked to the American public in his “fireside chats.” 

The Collection

After his death in 1945, FDR’s stamp collection was sold at auction. It was valued at $80,000, which would be about $1.5 million today. 

Documented provenance!

But it was not sold as a unit. Serious collectors of anything are seldom interested in purchasing a large ready-made collection. They want what they don’t have. 

Lotsa FDR stamps!

Therefore, it was sold in pages. Naturally, with the provenance of the President, including an authenticated note stating “from the collection of President Franklin D. Roosevelt”, the stamps brought many times that amount. The parts vastly outweighed the whole!

One can still obtain items from the collection. And more than 80 countries have issued their own stamps honoring U.S. President Franklin D. Roosevelt.

Sources:

Boller, Paul – Presidential Diversions: Presidents at Play: From George Washington to George W. Bush, Harcourt, 2007.

Davis, Kenneth – FDR: The Beckoning of Destiny – Putnam, 1971

Lippman, Theo. Jr. – The Squire of Warm Springs – Playboy Press, 1977

https://www.fdrlibrary.org/presidential-hobbies

https://postalmuseum.si.edu/fdr-stamp-collecting-president

https://www.apfelbauminc.com/fdr-stamp-collection/?srsltid=AfmBOopMFQUzF5d1cygl73A0mAPIjLz0yUJMmVESR2UDOrU0aqzF_VV1

Posted in A POTUS-FLOTUS Blog, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Nifty History People | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

The Presidents and the Exes: Part II

Everything was different after the Civil War

Money, Corruption, Business, Reconstruction, Immigration…

The thirty years leading to the Twentieth Century presented opportunities and problems our Founders would have never imagined! Railroads were crisscrossing the country in a week. Industry was booming. New inventions like electric light and the telephone, the typewriter and the elevator made cities rise high. And new jobs were created that had never been heard of before!

President Andrew Johnson

General, and now President Ulysses S. Grant was arguably the most famous person in the country if not the world when he was elected in 1868. Millard Fillmore, Franklin Pierce and Andrew Johnson were still living.  (Buchanan had died shortly before the election). Pierce died a year later, and would have been no help anyway. The once-genial New Hampshire man was now a cranky alcoholic. Millard Fillmore died a year after Pierce.

The Great General

That left Andrew Johnson, a man who Grant heartily disliked. During Johnson’s turbulent administration, he had courted the Hero of Appomattox assiduously, hoping to win his support. Grant obliged pleasantly at first, believing that a smooth transition was essential. The relationship soured quickly, and politics aside and personalities aside, Grant resented that he (and his post-war office as General in Chief) was being used to bolster the unpopular Johnson. 

President Grant

When Johnson died in 1875, Grant spent the rest of his second term with no living former President, not that he gave it a thought. Both his terms were fraught with scandals and corruption – some leading to the President himself, via close personal ties. (USG was always an honest man, and slimy money in his pocket was anathema.) Nevertheless, despite some genuine achievements, his administration was tainted, and he retired under clouds. He opted out of active political campaigning for his successor and focused on his round-the-world tour for two years. But he did provide a gracious, quiet White House dinner for the incoming President.

Rutherford B. Hayes, his successor, was an Ohio Republican of a reform-liberal (rather than spoils-system-patronage) sort, winning in a suspiciously corrupt election. He insisted on a squeaky-clean one-term administration. He vowed to remove troops from “unreconstructed” states (which he did), and banned spirits in the White House which gained him even more notoriety. He was decent enough, but none too popular; reformers seldom are. His White House was definitely squeaky-clean – but no fun. He returned to Ohio and devoted himself to veterans’ affairs and education pursuits and opportunities.

R.B. Hayes

When Grant returned from his long vacation, he discovered he was more popular than ever, especially among the politicians. Only 58, in need of a job and an income, he was coerced to become a candidate for another presidential term in 1880. He reluctantly agreed – and lost in a long, surprising nominating convention. 

James G. Garfield, another Ohioan of modest repute, was the surprise nominee, along with New Yorker Chester Arthur – of no repute. Garfield, POTUS for a brief 6-months fraught with political headaches, had an additional headache he did not expect: ex-President USG, his rival for the nomination. It was complicated, and neither the POTUS nor the “ex” were happy. Then Garfield was assassinated, and Chet Arthur finished the term, surprising most with his administrative abilities. But by the time his term ended, Grant was on his deathbed. So was Arthur. 

The Only Democrat…

Between the failed administration of James Buchanan and the three-way election in 1912 that elected Woodrow Wilson, there had been only one Democratic President in 65 years! (Andrew Johnson doesn’t really count, despite his lifelong association as a Dem; both he and Lincoln were elected on the “Union” ticket.) 

Interestingly enough, the five long decades dominated by Republican administrations, are essentially lopsided numbers. The actual elections were remarkably close! In some, the popular vote actually went to the Democrats; but the electoral vote was heavily Republican. The populous Northern cities “waved the bloody shirt”… i.e. responsible for the Civil War. Somebody had to take the blame. “Not all Democrats were Confederates of course, but all Confederates were Democrats”. The Solid South voted as one. And lost. 

Grover Cleveland, the only Democrat for decades!

Grover Cleveland won two non-consecutive terms (1885-9 and 1893-7) separated by Benjamin Harrison, of famous name-lineage, limpid personality and fairly decent accomplishments. Cleveland, a upstate-New Yorker, might have availed himself of Hayes’ experience, particularly since the conservative Democrat was always widely supported by the GOP. But he did not. The gruff, business attorney from Buffalo steered a straight business policy and never veered otherwise. And Hayes was happy in retirement.

The Benjamin Harrison sandwich

Of course, since the “sandwiched” Cleveland-Harrison-Cleveland elections meant that the ex-presidents actually campaigned against each other twice, any serious camaraderie other than good manners, would have been difficult. 

When Ohioan William McKinley led the Republican ticket in 1896 and in 1900, he faced 36-year-old William Jennings Bryan, an unlikely and unknown populist-leaning midwestern Democrat, who campaigned vigorously on a radical “free silver” monetary policy. By that time, former President Rutherford B. Hayes, long time and close friend and mentor of McKinley, had died.

The Democratic platform of that time was far to the left of even the mainstream Democrats, and positively petrified most of the Republicans. McKinley benefited from not only from the nod of Benjamin Harrison, but from a benignly “quiet” Grover Cleveland, who much preferred the genial and sound-money Republican candidate.

The genial William McKinley

After the scowly Cleveland and the icy Harrison, McKinley was a popular man and President. The country won a mercifully brief war with Spain. The bi-metal “free silver” issued had dissolved, and McKinley was a shoo-in for reelection. William Jennings Bryan opted to try again, and ex-POTUS Cleveland opted to keep a benign distance again.

William McKinley was elected to a second term – with even a bigger majority!

Sources:

Ackerman, Kenneth D. – The Dark Horse: The Surprise Election and Political Murder of President James A. Garfield. Carroll & Graf Publishers, 2003

Chernow, Ron – Grant – Penguin Press, 2017

Jeffers, H.Paul – An Honest President: The Life and Presidencies of Grover Cleveland – William Morrow, 2000

Rehnquist, William H. – Centennial Crisis: The Disputed Crisis of 1876 – Knopf, 2004

https://www.whitehousehistory.org/bios/ulysses-s-grant

https://millercenter.org/president/cleveland

https://mckinleymuseum.org/william-mckinley/

Posted in A POTUS-FLOTUS Blog, American Civil War, Andrew Johnson, Benjamin Harrison, Chester Arthur, Grover Cleveland, James Garfield, Rutherford Hayes, William McKinley | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Washington, Lafayette and the Bastille Key

George Washington was born to gentry. Lafayette was not.

Gentry George

The Father of our Country was born into a prosperous Colonial Virginia family in 1732. His father owned substantial acreage plus successful business enterprises, but it paled compared to the thousands of acres of the much wealthier planters.

Augustine Washington died when GW was eleven, the eldest son of his second wife. While young George was left comfortable property upon his maturity, the bulk of Augustine’s estate went to his two elder sons (by his first wife). Whatever dreams or aspirations he may have had for the classical London education his half-brothers received were dashed. 

Father and son illustration

Instead, GW was encouraged to train as a surveyor, then a respectable career for his social status. That in turn introduced him to the western part of the state, which in turn launched his military career in the Virginia Militia. 

Having been thwarted for advancement in the British Army several times over several years, and having inherited some nice property along the Potomac River, he was ready for a career change. As a planter. As soon-to-be ex-Colonel Washington, he also met and married Martha Custis, one of the wealthiest young widows in Virginia.

The Marquis

…Was born a Marquis – one of the highest ranks of French nobility. His father, died when young Gilbert-with-a-lot-of-middle-names-Motier, was a baby. Born in 1757, the orphaned child inherited the title of Marquis de Lafayette, plus enormous wealth, and became a ward of the King. He received an excellent education, heavy in military training.

The dapper Marquis

For reasons best known to himself, the nineteen year old Marquis became enthralled by the passions and politics of American Independence. With perhaps mild encouragement from Benjamin Franklin (then a minister to France), and persistence pleading his case to the French authorities, Lafayette used his own funds to recruit a regiment of soldiers and purchase/equip a sailing vessel to volunteer in the very-new United States army. 

Once Congress learned that the Marquis and company were willing to serve sans pay, they were happy to ship him off to General Washington, now 45, and in charge of the Continental Army. It took a little time, but young Lafayette a) endeared himself personally to Washington, and b) more importantly, proved himself a fine soldier, and a particularly able officer. And GW did not suffer fools gladly.

And as far as the Marquis was concerned, General Washington would be the father he never had. In fact, when the Frenchman’s first son was born, he named him Georges Washington Lafayette, and asked the General to be godfather. GW was honored. 

France: The Worsening of Times

When Lafayette returned to France in the mid-1780s, the contagion of revolution had taken hold in Paris, more mob-ruled upheaval than systematic political change. The monarchy of King Louis XVI, was teetering. The King, more inept than evil, finally agreed to revive the Estates General, a parliamentary assembly that had not been summoned for nearly 200 years. It was hailed as a great benefit to Frenchmen; all classes would be represented. 

French King Louis XVI

The Marquis was elected as a member of the nobility, but he was still infected with the cause of liberty, fraternity and maybe a little more equality. 

He renewed his American friendship with Thomas Jefferson (who he met superficially in Virginia), now sent by Congress to “succeed’ the aging Dr. Franklin. Lafayette was not yet 30, Jefferson, in his mid-40s. “The Rights of Man” are usually credited to the input of both men. 

Jefferson

King Louis also appointed Lafayette to take charge of the Paris National Guard, with responsibilities including the safety of the royal family. It was considered both an honor – and a practical move. Lafayette’s military and “revolutionary” credentials were impeccable. 

1789: The USA and France

No disrespect to Mr. Dickens, but the situation between the USA and France in 1789 was also “the best of times, the worst of times.”

Eighteen months earlier, the failures of the Articles of Confederation, designed to govern the new country, had been scrapped in favor of a completely new constitution. Within a year, a majority of States ratified the document; the rest followed accordingly. One of the provisions called for the election of a President as the country’s Chief Executive, along with a Congress (legislative) and a Supreme Court (judiciary).

No American was more respected and regarded than George Washington, the former General who had voluntarily relinquished his commission in order to return to his beloved Mount Vernon plantation. Even King George III, when he heard the news, said that Washington would be the most famous man in the world.

That he would also be his country’s first president was practically a given; his election was unanimous. Peacefully. Twice. 

Alas in France, the fond wisps of hope via the Estates General and even the seriously weakened King Louis strained to the point of breaking. The have-nots of mob rule demanded off-with-their-heads punishment for the nobility, who had taxed them to death to pay for their private luxuries. 

The Bastille

…was an old fortress-prison in the middle of Paris, and on July 14, 1789, it held only seven scraggy prisoners, mostly defective or indigent. It was already slated for demolition, but it was a mighty symbol of oppression.

The mob, armed with farm tools and whatever could do damage, assaulted the prison and released the prisoners. Then they tore it down, brick by brick. The Marquis de Lafayette, as head of the Paris National Guard managed to obtain its key, and helped prevent mob panic. 

The key to the Bastille

Believing that the symbol of the “we-the-people” French Revolution would find no better home in posterity, he sent the key to the Bastille to his beloved “father” George Washington. 

It remains at Mount Vernon to this day.

Sources:

Brookheiser, Richard – Founding Father: Rediscovering George Washington – The Free Press, 1996

Malone, Dumas – Jefferson and the Rights of Man (Vol. 2) – Little, Brown, 1951

Unger, Harlow Giles – Lafayette – John Wiley & Sons, 2002

https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/february-4/first-u-s-president-elected

https://www.britannica.com/biography/Marquis-de-Lafayette/The-French-Revolution

https://www.monticello.org/research-education/thomas-jefferson-encyclopedia/marquis-de-lafayette/

https://www.mountvernon.org/library/digitalhistory/digital-encyclopedia/article/marquis-de-lafayette

Posted in A POTUS-FLOTUS Blog, George Washington, Nifty History People | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

The Presidents and the Exes: Part I

Pals, Foes and No-Shows

Ex-Presidents in General: The Early Fellows

It’s lonely at the top. Just about every President has said so. Most come with their own agendas and plans, and all will quickly learn that they can go awry quickly. Some wonderful intentions can be changed in a moment. Think Pearl Harbor, or September 11th. It is imperative to be able to change course, play by ear, or dissolve into analysis-paralysis. 

A former President can offer good advice. Or concrete suggestions. Or moral support.  If requested. Some sitting POTUSes, like John Adams, actively sought support and input from a somewhat reluctant George Washington (who alas, had no former President to turn to). Nevertheless, GW was happy to oblige – however he could.

Thomas Jefferson and Adams had fallen out after a long friendship, but later Presidents James Madison and James Monroe, long-time personal and political friends of Jefferson, frequently consulted him on various issues. Mostly as a sounding board. Jeff was more than happy to weigh in as he saw fit. JA was left out.

The Virginia Triumverate

All President are aware of, and usually basically acquainted with their immediate predecessor(s). But some don’t like them – personally or politically. Acerbic John Quincy Adams got along well with Madison and Monroe, his predecessors, but equally testy Andrew Jackson loathed John Quincy Adams, the man who previously sat in his chair. The feeling was mutual. JQA did not even attend Jackson’s inauguration, ostensibly because he did not want to shake his hand. Jax wasn’t wild about Monroe either.

John Quincy Adams was an anomaly. Some time after retiring from the Presidency, he was elected to Congress – a different branch of government – where he served till his death 17 years later. He couldn’t be involved with his successors, and had little regard for any of their abilities anyway.

John Quincy Adams

Martin Van Buren, Jax hand-picked successor, reaped the whirlwind (and blame) for much of Jackson’s banking policies, but the two men remained cordial enough. 

John Tyler’s immediate predecessor, William Henry Harrison, died after only a month in office. He might have benefited by some presidential guidance, but the Harrison-Tyler ticket had challenged Van Buren, and there were cool feelings. Tyler also disliked Jackson and JQA – and it was mutual. 

Andrew Jackson

James Knox Polk was disinclined to ask anyone for input, except perhaps Andrew Jackson, his lifelong mentor. But Jax was elderly and died shortly after Polk took office. Martin Van Buren, once he got over his miff that he wasn’t chosen as Democratic candidate instead, is said to have vigorously supported Polk, but was re-miffed when he did not receive high appointed office. 

General Zachary Taylor did not like his predecessor, period, but Polk died just months after he left office. Then Taylor died, leaving poor Millard Fillmore with only two ex-Presidents to turn to: Martin Van Buren, a fellow New Yorker, and John Tyler. They didn’t even agree with each other, let alone with Fillmore-the-Whig. There was no significant relationship between them. Ol’ Mill was on his own. He no doubt tried his best and meant well…

Millard Fillmore

On the Eve of Civil War

The 1850s were tough times destined to get worse. Franklin Pierce was also on his own and a “dark horse” like Polk. The New Hampshire Democrat had long standing pleasant relationships with both Van Buren and Tyler, but by this time, slavery had become front-and-center on the national agenda. Both Van Buren (now a Free Soil nominee) and Tyler (a Southern slave owner) kept a polite-but-cool distance. Millard Fillmore was pleasant at the inaugural, but his wife died soon afterwards, and MF went abroad for a while.

Aging Pennsylvania Democrat James Buchanan, elected in 1856 mainly because he had spent the last four years abroad in a diplomatic post, had known all Presidents from Monroe forward. Van Buren, Tyler, Fillmore and Pierce were still living. Pierce had gone abroad for a while, as did Van Buren and Fillmore. Buck, with a long political resume, had known Tyler for a long time, but they were not closely allied. Nevertheless, in 1861, prior to Lincoln’s inauguration, a Peace Conference, a last ditch effort to present options to avoid the looming “irrepressible conflict” was held in Washington. Aging Ex-President John Tyler was named Conference President, and met with President Buchanan to present the committee’s recommendations. Buchanan was cordial, but non-committal. He preferred that his successor make those decisions. Tyler was later elected to the Confederate Congress, but died just prior to taking office.

James Buchanan

Abraham Lincoln had five living former presidents to advise him. Tyler was still living (briefly), as were Van Buren, Fillmore, Pierce and Buchanan. He made a courtesy call to Buchanan shortly before his inaugural. It was pleasant, but Buck had no advice – other than to suggest that the new POTUS take advantage of a pleasant cottage at the Soldier’s Home a few miles from the capital. It was much cooler in the heat of summer. At least that was good advice.

Lincoln had paid a courtesy call to Fillmore en route to Washington, and Pierce disliked both Lincoln and his policies, and was vocal about it. There is indication he suggested that the living ex-Presidents be summoned to co-run the country. Nevertheless, he did send a heartfelt condolence letter when eleven-year-old Willie Lincoln died. It is very likely that Lincoln sent a graceful acknowledgment, but that letter has never surfaced. 

Lincoln

When Andrew Johnson took his subdued private oath of office after Lincoln’s assassination, Tyler and Van Buren had already died. As a long-time Tennessee Senator, Johnson had a poor opinion of aging James Buchanan, who he considered weak and timid. “Buck” died shortly after Johnson’s term. VP-turned-POTUS Fillmore was supportive of Johnson’s reconstruction policies. He would have been happy to meet with him, but there is no indication that AJ ever asked him.  

Stay tuned.

Sources:

Gutzman, Kevin R.C. – The Jeffersonians: The Visionary Presidencies of Jefferson, Madison, and Monroe – St. Martin’s Press, 2022

Shafer, Ron G. – The Carnival Campaign: How the Rollicking 1840 Campaign of “Tippecanoe and Tyler Too”: Changed Presidential Elections Forever – The Chicago Press, 2017

https://www.britannica.com/biography/Andrew-Jackson

https://www.britannica.com/biography/James-Buchanan-president-of-United-States

https://www.loc.gov/resource/mal.1479200/?st=text

Posted in A POTUS-FLOTUS Blog, Andrew Jackson, Andrew Johnson, Franklin Pierce, George Washington, James Buchanan, James K. Polk, James Madison, James Monroe, John Adams, John Quincy Adams, John Tyler, Martin Van Buren, Millard Fillmore | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

POTUS Harding and the Camping Trip

All Presidents need personal relaxation – and fun.

The President’s Angsts

By his own admission, Warren G. Harding was ill-equipped to be President. He stated many times (usually to private friends), that he was unqualified for the post. He did not lie. His experience as a newspaper publisher and state legislator was satisfactory and perhaps qualified him to serve as Senator, albeit not in any leadership capacity. He never introduced legislation of any major significance. 

His business acumen was modest, and generally on a lower level. (His own Marion Star newspaper was successful, but it was a small-town paper). He had little experience in economics and finance. His international diplomatic skills were untested and negligible. 

WGH looked like a president.

He was also ill equipped for the position by nature. He was an accommodating person rather than one to shoulder the hard calls. Or the hard work. Or the hard issues that invariably confront every sitting President. 

But on the plus side, he knew it. 

One time he complained to his secretary about the amount of work there was, and was advised that perhaps he should curtail the public meet-and-greets that had been a part of presidential tradition since George Washington. “If you cancel the twice weekly ‘open house’ for an hour and a half, you will have an extra three hours a week.” “But meeting the public is the only thing I enjoy about the job, and probably the only thing I am good at,” he sighed. 

He didn’t lie about that either.

Warren Harding was a genial fellow with many friends. He had a natural talent for the glad-hand, and his “how ya doin’” and “nice to see ya” was absolutely sincere. It was part of what made him a popular speaker from OH civic groups, to national political exposure across the country. But again, by his own admission, he preferred just being one of the guys in the foursome on the golf course. He wasn’t particularly good at golf, but it was enjoyable!

The Foursome, Sans Golf, Sans President

There was a foursome, but not a golfing group. For a half dozen years, four of the best known men in the country, all notable high achievers, went on a camping trip for a week or two in various locations in the Appalachian Mountains.

Thomas Edison

Thomas Edison, inventor of you-name-it, Henry Ford, the car guy, Harvey Firestone, the rubber king, and John Burroughs, the foremost naturalist/conservationist in the country, had become great personal friends, and made time for friendship and relaxation. They called their group “The Vagabonds.” This was definitely not just a fishing-buddy trip; their excursion into various deep woods was made with guides, cooks, baggage handlers, horses, maintenance fellows, etc. They had a grand time!

Henry Ford
Harvey Firestone

But in March 1921, John Burroughs died. There was an opening in the foursome. Harvey Firestone, looking for a little extra publicity for their illustrious group, came up with the idea to invite the newly elected President to join the excursion. The “threesome” knew that having the POTUS along, even for the weekend, was definitely a nice perk for them. All of them had business issues they hoped to discuss with the President. Privately.

Warren Harding was delighted to accept. It was one of his perks. He also knew, if nothing else, that he was pretty congenial company even without the presidency. It might actually be a lot of fun! The past six months of campaigning and preparing for his new job had been very stressful.

The Foursome, Sans Golf, With President, With Wives

Of course the “presidency” required conditions. The President insisted that the campsite had to be in near proximity to Washington. Secret Service agents were required. A professional photographer was required. A movie crew (which obviously pleased Mr. Edison) was included. A large press contingent was essential all all. Harding’s group alone was more than 40 personnel.

More than a foursome!

A site tucked within view of the gorgeous Blue Ridge, in remote, tiny Pectonville, Maryland was chosen. While it was near enough to a main road, the campsite was accessible only via a bridge to the private property. It could be easily protected by the Secret Service contingent.

And, perhaps at the urging of Mrs. Harding, for the first time, wives would be included. She wanted to go! Alas, to her great disappointment, she caught a bad cold and had to cancel at the last minute. WGH went anyway, but only stayed for two days. The Missus Edison, Ford and Firestone went anyway also. With hats and dresses – and sensible shoes!

WGH and friends…

Luxury Camping

It was not exactly what The Vagabonds usually experienced. Nevertheless, they were not getting any younger, (Edison was 74!) and all had the wherewithal to do practically whatever they liked. Like traveling by motor cars and trucks that could accommodate more than 40 people – rather than just their usual horses.

…Riding out

Two specially-built trucks were in their caravan. One was refrigerated for the hundreds of pounds of perishables they required. The other was filled with their kitchen sundries and every possible utensil and crockery imaginable. Other large trucks carried tents and cots, camp chairs and bedding and all the tools necessary to set up camp. They even brought along an electric player-piano for entertainment. The entire contingent was estimated at more than 100.

But they found time for some horseback riding, fishing and doing the usual camping chores. WGH was assigned to chop firewood, but soon handed his axe over to Henry Ford.

But gathering in the dining tent swapping stories was delightful! The President was happy. And the food was good.

The plaque

Today, the campsite is within Camp Harding Park. With a suitable plaque.

Sources:

Guinn, Jeff – The Vagabonds: The Story of Henry Ford and Thomas Edison’s Ten-Year Road Trip. Simon & Schuster, 2020.

Sinclair, Andrew – The Available Man – MacMillan, 1965

https://www.whitehousehistory.org/bios/warren-g-harding

https://boundarystones.weta.org/2023/08/30/president-harding-and-vagabonds

https://dnr.maryland.gov/pages/md-conservation-history/travelerspart2.aspx

Posted in A POTUS-FLOTUS Blog, Nifty History People, Warren G. Harding | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Woodrow Wilson. Dr. Grayson. Edith. And Golf.

Most of our 20th Century (and later) Presidents played golf.

For Medicinal Purposes

At his inaugural luncheon at the White House, the new President Woodrow Wilson had occasion to meet naval physician Dr. Cary Grayson, and invited him to become his personal physician. A few days later, when Grayson gave the POTUS a thorough examination (with medical history), he was amazed to discover the 56-year-old man Woodrow Wilson was in startling poor health. 

Prescription for golf.

While some of the President’s conditions were not able to be cured, his hardening of the arteries for one, and his high-strung nature for another. But certain “lifestyle changes” could alleviate problems, at least partially. Like a bland diet for his sensitive digestive system. Or fresh air and exercise. Or making time for relaxation. 

Grayson had prescribed “golf” as a suitable activity for the intellectual scholar and sedentary man, and Wilson actually began to feel better. And, to make sure that his most important patient was abiding to the treatment, Dr. Grayson became his regular golf buddy. They became fast friends. 

Wilson the Golfer

Woodrow Wilson had always been what one might call a “sports enthusiast.” He managed the baseball team at college, and attended football games regularly. He was a fan. A cheerleader. But seldom an active player. Occasional horseback outings, or long walks or bicycle rides was the extent of his athletic participation. 

Neither Wilson nor Grayson were good golfers and never improved despite regular golf games. According to Col. Edmund Starling, the White House Secret Service agent assigned to accompany them, they were pretty evenly matched “four-putters,” and seldom played a round in less than 200 strokes. In a word: duffers.

Col. Edmund Starling

But they enjoyed it. And WW, with immense powers of focus and concentration, was able to focus that concentration on the golf course, and actually reduced the growing stresses of his office. 

The Devastation

Only eighteen months after Wilson’s inauguration, First Lady Ellen Wilson died. She had an un- or misdiagnosed Bright’s Disease for years, then always fatal. Wilson’s 30-year marriage had been a very happy one, and unusually close. Nobody knew him better than Ellen. Her loss devastated the President, and his emotional health, always fragile, was coming apart. 

He lost weight (and he was never heavy), he couldn’t sleep. Or focus or concentrate. On top of that, Ellen’s death came just as the opening shots were fired of what would be The Great War (WWI). 

Cary Grayson’s rounds of golf with his patient were now essential to the President’s health. 

Cousin Helen

Coincidences

After Ellen’s death, the President had asked his unmarried 38-year-old cousin Helen Bones to come live at the White House and assume the “First Lady” social responsibilities. She was happy to do so, but was a stranger to Washington. Dr. Grayson sensed her loneliness, and introduced her Edith Galt, a 42-year-old widow. 

Grayson had known Edith for several years, and believed the two women would have many things in common. Coincidentally, the doctor was courting a young woman who had become close to Edith when her parents died, and hoped that the Widow Galt might encourage his romantic attentions. 

As it was, Helen Bones and Edith Galt became good friends. They shopped and took long walks. Went to lunch. It was pleasant company. So much so, that one afternoon, when the two women were caught in a sudden downpour close to the White House, Helen invited her companion to come in for tea.

Coincidentally, at the elevator, they met the President and Dr. Grayson, who had been caught in the same downpour on the golf course. Wilson and the Doctor invited themselves to the tea party, and the rest became history. 

Edith and Woodrow: Newlyweds

As “Cousin Helen’s friend,” Edith now received invitations to lunch or dinner at the White House, He phoned her daily on a newly-installed private line, and invited her to join them on a carriage ride, or a theater performance… It did not take very long for Edith Galt to realize she was being courted.

Less than 18 months after Ellen Wilson’s death, the President remarried. It had been Ellen’s dying wish that Dr. Grayson “take care of Woodrow,” and knew her husband’s visceral need for a woman’s nurturing love. 

The Bride and The Diagnosis

Cary Grayson had known Mrs. Galt a long time, and as the new Mrs. Wilson, he took her into his confidence regarding her new husband’s health – which was not very good. He entrusted her to make sure he adhered to his “healthy” diet, and see to it that he has plenty of rest and relaxation. He stressed that it was essential.

She took Grayson’s charge very seriously, especially since the War was wreaking havoc throughout Europe and beyond. 

Grayson suggested that the new bride might want to join them on the golf course, and asked if she played? Actually she did on occasion, enjoyed the outings, was happy to go along and confessed that she played reasonably well – for a woman.

The happy couple.

In the memoirs she wrote twenty years afterwards, she recalled that the newlyweds rose early – by 6 AM, had coffee in their rooms, and then went out to play nine holes of golf before returning for a nourishing breakfast. She admitted that neither of them were particularly good golfers, but the fresh air and exercise was good for them. They had fun and laughed a lot. Sometimes Dr. Grayson joined them.

But it was Col. Starling, their unheralded escort, who provided the final analysis. Edith Wilson, while not a particularly good golfer – was a lot better than either of her companions!

Sources:

Heckscher, Augustus – Woodrow Wilson: A Biography – Scribner’s – 1991

Weinstein, Edwin A. – Woodrow Wilson: A Medical and Psychological Biography – Princeton University Press, 1981

Starling, Col. Edmund (as told to Thomas Sugrue) – Simon & Schuster, 1946

Wilson, Edith Bolling – My Memoir – Bobbs Merrill, 1938

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/02/02/AR2007020201698.html?noredirect=on

Posted in A POTUS-FLOTUS Blog, Nifty History People, Woodrow Wilson | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Theodore Roosevelt and the Pigskin Library

Being a POTUS is a hard act to follow.

The Young Retiree

Theodore Roosevelt was our youngest President, only 42 when he took office. After seven-and-a-half years, declaring that he would not seek a third term, he was also our youngest ex-President. He was only 50, and at the peak of his physical and mental energies. 

Having hand-picked his successor, William H. Taft, he sought to allow the new POTUS the latitude he needed to chart his own direction. Serendipitously, The Smithsonian Institution had paved a smooth transition for TR – offering him an underwritten safari in Africa, with a supporting cast of hundreds, in exchange for regular articles and exotic specimens. They knew Roosevelt’s devotion and expertise as a naturalist, and expected grand results. And publicity.

Big Bill Taft needed room.

TR was dee-lighted for this mammoth opportunity, which also provided the material for dozens of magazine articles and a few books. He took Kermit with him. Kermit was his second son, and perhaps the most like his father when it came to the “strenuous” outdoor life. He gladly took a year off from his studies at Harvard for this once-in-a-lifetime father-and-son adventure. 

A Segue Back to Jefferson

Theodore Roosevelt was not a huge admirer of Thomas Jefferson, and said as much periodically. (Jefferson, having died decades before TR was born, remained silent on the subject.)

TJ and TR had commonalities.

Nevertheless, just as a broken clock is right twice a day, there were huge undeniable similarities between the two men. TJ was a knowledgeable and passionate agronomist. TR was a knowledgeable and passionate zoologist. Natural history is natural history. And passion and knowledge is passion and knowledge.

And while it is Jefferson who is remembered as saying, “I cannot live without books,” I doubt that Roosevelt would challenge either the words or the sentiment. He was a voracious book-a-day reader. 

Corinne

Corinne Roosevelt, TR’s younger sister, was devoted to her brother, as were all his family members. She had married a wealthy real estate manager Douglas Robinson, an ardent supporter of the Roosevelts, who denied his wife nothing that money could buy. 

Corinne Roosevelt Robinson

So when TR was in the retiring-cum-safari mode, Corinne wanted to give him a suitable gift, and asked him what he would like. He knew exactly what he wanted. 

In addition to all the related paraphernalia he would require for the months-long adventure, he could not go without books! A large assortment of them. But he also needed volumes that could withstand the wear and tear, be impervious to the weather and climate, the sand and the heat and the rains, the molds and the mildews, blood and gun oil and all the critters that might invade his tents. 

TR believed that “pigskin” was the most suitable binding material for his needs. Pigskin, a century-old nickname for a football, is as tough as it gets! Old bindings were removed, the margins were trimmed for space/weight, and an aluminum case was designed specifically to carry them. The set weighed 60 pounds.

It was a private one-of-one edition of TR’s favorite reading material. And the well-tuned-in father made sure to consult Kermit on his favorites as well! 

Kermit had TR’s hunting and reading and poetry genes.

Sixty books (or maybe fifty-nine) were chosen for special binding. The variety of them is a picture of the man himself – an amalgam of many different interests.

The Bible, of course. Volumes of Shakespeare, of course. The ancient classics – like the Iliad and the Odyssey, of course. Plays by Euripides.

Then there was a huge selection of poetry. All Roosevelts were drawn to poetry, and memorized hundreds of lines of verse. The range was interesting: Milton. Edgar Allan Poe. Robert Browning and Ralph Waldo Emerson. Shelly and Keats – and Longfellow.

Then there were some Dickens’ titles. And Sir Walter Scott adventures. Both Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn represented Mark Twain. Robinson Crusoe, and Pilgrims’ Progress, Don Quixote and even Alice in Wonderland made the list as well. 

And, perhaps to keep TR focused on the intellectual present, he included Darwin’s Origin of the Species, Alfred Thayer Mahan’s The Influence of Sea Power on History, which had been a major influence on TR (personally and presidentially!) And The Federalist Papers.

A reader is a reader – anywhere!

According to TR himself, in his African Game Trails, the books were not for ornament. He always carried some volume with him, either in his saddle bag or his cartridge bag. If he rested for a while in the shade or waiting for camp to be pitched, out came one of his books, for a half hour or so reading pleasure. The books were used, and used hard. By the end of the year-long safari, TR claimed that the bindings looked like a “well-used saddle.” They held up. 

Where Are They Now?

The Pigskin Library was eventually given to TR’s daughter Ethel Derby, who kept them for decades, and finally gifted them to the Theodore Roosevelt collection in Harvard’s Houghton Library.

But… while Harvard still maintains a vast TR collection…and while the Roosevelt home at Sagamore Hill also maintains a substantial collection in its “Presidential Library”…

The newest TR library is set to open in 2026.

… a new Theodore Roosevelt Library is being built in Dickinson, North Dakota – not far from the ranch where he spent a few momentous years as a cowboy following the death of his young first wife. Most historians agree that the experience helped forge the man he became.

According to their plans, the Pigskin Library will be a part of its collection. 

One can imagine a heartfelt “Bully!” from its previous owner.

Sources: 

Brands, H.W. – TR: The Last Romantic – Basic Books, 1997

Morris, Edmund – Colonel Roosevelt – Random House, 2010

Roosevelt, Theodore – African Game Trails – Scribner’s, 1910

http://www.eyewitnesstohistory.com/tr.htm

https://www.si.edu/object/auth_exp_fbr_EACE0006

https://www.theodorerooseveltcenter.org/Research/Digital-Library/Record?libID=o274791

Posted in A POTUS-FLOTUS Blog, Nifty History People, Theodore Roosevelt, Thomas Jefferson, William Howard Taft | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

U.S. Grant and the Wildflowers

Ulysses S. Grant was a true case of still waters running deep.

The Young Romantic

Hiram Ulysses Grant (his name at birth) was an amalgam of both his parents: the tenacity of his father and the taciturnity of his mother. He did not give up easily (if at all), and he did not talk much – unless he had something worth saying.

As the eldest of six siblings, he had plenty of family companionship and was well liked among his schoolmates and neighbors. But his best affinity was with horses. By the time he was eight or nine, he had established himself as a fine horseman, with “a way with the animals.” 

His life and his name changed when he was enrolled at West Point. The “Hiram” part was dropped (nobody ever called him Hiram, anyway), and the “S” was an assumption from his Congressman, since his mother’s maiden name was “Simpson.” Ulysses S. Grant never changed it. 

He was a middle-of-the-class student throughout, except for his horsemanship, where he excelled. But he had discovered “novels.” He readily admitted preferring the latest novels to the classics and military histories proscribed by the Academy. 

He also made friends. Some were for life, no matter how their paths diverged.

One good friend was his senior class roommate, Frederick Dent. Upon their graduation in 1839, knowing his pal was assigned to Jefferson Barracks in St. Louis, a popular first deployment for new officers, Dent urged Grant to visit his folks, who lived nearby.

The Dent home – it was white then.

Sure enough, once USG had settled in, he rode out to White Haven, the Dent home, where he was warmly welcomed and told “not to be a stranger.” The Dents were a lively bunch, and the invitation to Sunday dinners were eagerly accepted. 

A few months later, he met the Dent’s eldest daughter Julia, just graduated from finishing school. It was love at first sight. 

The Making of a Romance

Grant was only 21, about 5’8” and perhaps 140 lbs. No beard. Unprepossessing. Still shy with women, there was something about Julia that found its way into his heart and soul. 

She was far from a conventional beauty, in fact no beauty at all. Barely 18, average in height, with a build that promised to become stout with age and childbearing, she was born with an eye condition that caused one eye to turn inward at will. Since it caused chronic eye strain, her family and teachers were lenient when it came to “close” work: reading, writing, and academics in general. 

Young Julia Dent Grant

But Julia’s lack of physical beauty never seemed to be a problem for her. She was genuinely outgoing and pleasant, and always had plenty of friends – and suitors. 

Grant was attracted because they were comfortable together. He could talk to her. She was sympathetic. She was honest. She was fun to be with. He began showing up at the Dent home more often – mostly to see Julia. 

With four older brothers, she was obliged to be a tomboy, and could climb and run and fish. And an excellent horsewoman. This appealed to USG, who now had a companion for an afternoon’s ride. 

As the weeks passed, and winter became spring, the two periodically took sketchbooks and a picnic basket to a particularly lovely grove in the woods. They were falling in love.

When Grant was reassigned to Louisiana, he became depressed at the thought of leaving the young woman he wanted to marry. But before leaving for his new post, the two became secretly engaged. Julia knew her father would object; not for Grant himself (who he liked), but because they were too young, and second lieutenants do not earn very much. They decided to wait. And exchange letters.

They did not know it at the time, but they would only see each other once during the next four years. 

Wildflowers

The assignment in Louisiana led to Grant’s next assignment in the Mexican War. It was a foreign country – during wartime. Sending and receiving mail was long and arduous. Weeks passed before mail arrived.

Grant wrote often, with a surprising fluidity and ease of style. His prose was direct, sincere and without the common Victorian affectation. Julia wrote sporadically, perhaps one letter to his five. Warmly, but very much within the limits learned in school. 

Julia mentioned the story.

Nevertheless, in one of her letters, she mentioned re-visiting the grove in the woods where they enjoyed picnicking. It was spring and the wildflowers were abundant, so she picked a few – and enclosed them in her letter.

Alas, and despite the charming gesture, the time and distance and had turned the enclosed flowers to straw, and all that was left were flaky petals, dried leaves and dust. When Grant opened the envelope in a secluded spot in his wooded encampment, a stiff wind blew whatever was left of the precious flowers away.

He later told her that he spent the next two hours chasing a few remnants of her handpicked present in order to preserve the dear gift that her hands had touched. He was unsuccessful. Most of the petals had disintegrated and were at the mercy of the wind. 

True Love

At the end of the War, USG came to collect his intended. He was now 26, tanned, muscular, and a brevet Captain. She was 22, and old enough for marriage. They had waited, and their happy reunion immediately surrounded their unchanged feelings of four years earlier. 

The happy couple.

Their love was true and deep, with the loyalty and sincerity that Grant needed and Julia was happy to provide. It would last for forty years, through thick and thin.

Sources:

Grant, Julia Dent, (Simon, John Y. Ed.) – The Personal Memoirs of Julia Dent Grant – G.P. Putnam’s Sons, 1975

Korda, Michael – Ulysses S. Grant, The Unlikely Hero – Atlas Books, 2004

Ross, Ishbel – The General’s Wife – Dodd, Mead, 1959

https://millercenter.org/president/grant/life-before-the-presidency

https://www.whitehousehistory.org/bios/ulysses-s-grant

https://libguides.css.edu/usgrant/home/usgrant/julia

Posted in A POTUS-FLOTUS Blog, American Civil War, Ulysses S. Grant | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

John Tyler and the American Beethoven

An invitation to perform at the White House is a coup! It looks very good on ones resume!

The American Beethoven

Anthony Philip Heinrich (1781-1861), was a Bohemian-born American composer. Born to a prosperous Czech family, he came late to his professional musical career. The family business was a thriving one, and as its scion, he was expected to carry it on, which he did. Alas, it was lost during the Napoleonic Wars. His plans changed.

Finding himself stranded and near-penniless in Boston in 1810, and primarily self-taught, he decided to pursue his lifelong passion in music. Within a few years, he took a 700-mile journey through Pennsylvania, all the way to Kentucky, and discovered the new musical sounds of the American frontier. Perhaps like Aaron Copland more than a century later, he translated those “natural” sounds into a body of original work, including birds and Indian chants, amalgamating them with the traditional European models of musical composition. By 1822, he was being hailed as the “American Beethoven,” since, it is said, he introduced the composer’s symphonies to a new audience. Then he parlayed his own growing prominence and talents into performing his compositions on the pianoforte.

Anthony Philip Heinrich

By the 1840s, he was a celebrated and dominant figure in concert circles, with a wide range of prominent lawyers, judges, writers and poets in his circle. His musical reputation was made!

His tour de force circa 1840, was a suite of compositions, celebrating the growth of his adopted United States of America, from the Mayflower on forward. By the early 1840s, John Tyler was President, having succeeded to the office after the death of William Henry Harrison.

The American President

John Tyler was a Virginia of prominence. Born in 1790, his was a well established family of the “triple” professions: planter, lawyer and political statesman. His father, also a John Tyler, served as Virginia’s Governor. 

The younger Tyler was given an excellent education. He studied at the College of William and Mary, became an attorney, and by the time he was in his late twenties, was a Congressman. He had also studied music, a common requisite for most well-born Colonial youngsters. In Tyler’s case, it was the violin. It is also said he had a pleasant singing voice. 

His musical tastes were prosaic, and perhaps even more so by the time he was President. To him the newfangled “waltz” was “seductive” and the wild “polka” was unbecoming. Both types were banned in the early Tyler White House.

By the time he was President (1841-45), he had married and sired eight children, seven living to maturity. His wife, the former Letitia Christian, had suffered a debilitating stroke, and died by 1842.

Letitia Tyler, the First Mrs T.

Since inviting gifted professional musicians and composers to perform for a select audience at the White House has been a time honored event since George Washington, it stood to reason that the POTUS would offer invitations periodically to provide entertainment for his guests. 

Anthony Philip Heinrich was delighted to perform.  

The Concert

Heinrich wore his best formal attire, including his hat, his walking stick, his gloves, and his portfolio of music, including the most recent sections. 

He sat at the pianoforte, and proceeded to perform his tour de force – with all the passion and enthusiasm that a composer brings to the composition. “It is said” that his head bobbed up and down, and his shoulders heaved with each crescendo, as the chords rose and fell. 

This was a musical style or genre that was likely unfamiliar to the more pedestrian tastes of Tyler and his guests. They were accustomed to the old Scottish ballads. And the lively reels and folk dances. Maybe a little Mozart or Schubert. Heinrich’s compositions – and performance style – while original and creative, was eccentric and strange to them. 

Perhaps sensing the lack of response from his guests, Tyler approached the pianist and gently and respectfully (he was a very respectful southern gentleman) suggested that maybe “you could play a good old Virginia reel.” 

Heinrich was incensed. “I never play dance music,” he is said to have commented, as he rose, rolled up his music, took his hat, cane and gloves – and portfolio, and departed abruptly.

It is further said, that he commented to a friend who had accompanied him to the White House, that “the American electorate should be hanged,” since their President had no more musical taste than an oyster.”

The source.

Perhaps. Heinrich was obviously not happy. 

Epilogue 1:

Tyler’s first wife, the former Letitia Christian had suffered a severe and debilitating stroke some time before he became President. After her death, Tyler married a woman much younger (30 years!), much more sophisticated (world traveled), and much wealthier ($$$) than he was. Nevertheless, it was a happy and fruitful union, since they also had seven children together. John Tyler was 70 when his last child was born, about a year before he died.

Julia Gardiner Tyler had some musical talents herself. She played the guitar, and was said to have a pleasant singing voice.

The “Second” Tylers

In their post-Presidential retirement lives, many an evening was spent in their parlor, he playing the violin, she the guitar, and both singing duets – likely the old Scottish ballads and lively reels!

Epilogue 2:

Anthony Philip Heinrich, alas, did not fare as well. He was prolific, but his American audience and the American orchestras were lacking in their appreciation. Before the Civil War, he found himself performing in Europe, where he was treated with more artistic regard.

Nevertheless, he died at 80 in New York, not long before John Tyler died in Virginia. In poverty.

But occasionally his works are performed today. He would be pleased.

Sources:

Boller, Paul – Presidential Diversions: Presidents at Play: From George Washington to George W. Bush, Harcourt, 2007.

Kirk, Elise – Music at the White House – University of Illinois Press, 1986

https://firstladies.org/home/first-ladies/julia-tyler

https://www.whitehousehistory.org/bios/john-tyler

Posted in A POTUS-FLOTUS Blog, John Tyler, Nifty History People | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

First Families of Prohibition

Five Presidential Couples lived in the White House between 1920 and 1933: The Prohibition Years.

A Long Simmering Issue

Of course nobody is in favor of drunkenness! And a traditionally Puritan ethic made public intoxication a cause for shame and ridicule for centuries. By the Civil War, “prohibition,” and its softer companion “temperance” had become a potent issue: enough to encourage political action, especially once slavery had been abolished.

Women and clergy were usually at the forefront of banning liquor of all kinds, with the possible exception of ceremonial wine for religious purposes. And maybe for medicinal use. By the late 19th century, the Women’s Christian Temperance Union (still around!) had become a formidable bastion for moral causes, and “lips that touch liquor shall never touch mine” were on a great many pious lips. 

With the huge influx of immigrants in the later decades of the century, thousands of saloons catered to the thirsts of tired and poor laborers, some of whom needed respite from a tenement full of underfed children and an exhausted wife, as well as from long hours in sweatshops.

It seemed that the poorer the neighborhood, the greater the imprint of John Barleycorn. Pastors were supportive of prohibition. Newspapers published sad tales of five-year-olds being sent to fetch their drunken father from the saloon. Politicians started to cater to the voters aligning in the new “moral crusade.” 

Towns passed laws banning liquor. A few larger cities were joining the banned wagon. A Constitutional amendment was believed necessary to keep Americans sober. But enjoying a drink or two – or three, is a far cry from drunkenness!

By 1919, enough states had ratified the prohibition amendment to make it illegal throughout the entire country. Despite its piety, it was definitely NOT popular in either political party: You cannot legislate morality. They’ve been saying that for centuries!

And that included the five Presidential occupants entrusted to enforce it. 

The Wilsons

The Wilsons

Democrat Woodrow Wilson and his second wife Edith Galt had more pressing things on their plates than Prohibition. WW had tried very hard to keep the USA out of the Great War – for three years. When international matters became too intolerable for neutrality, it seemed more important than a beer. Besides, his own heart was completely subsumed in creating a League of Nations to prevent future wars.

Moreover, Wilson was not a teetotaler. Nor was Mrs. Wilson. They were both cosmopolitan, hardly drunkards, and both enjoyed a potable libation periodically. He actually vetoed the Volstead Act (as unenforceable), but Congress overrode it.

In January, 1920, the 18th Amendment was enacted into law, and WW had suffered a severe stroke, and next 18th months were focused on his health, and the extent of his disabilities, both temporary and permanent.

The Hardings

There was never going to be a way that Republican Warren Harding supported Prohibition, other than lip-service (required as President), and finagling around it, by putting a time limit on the “Noble Experiment.” They were social. They were political. Social and political is usually laced. 

The Hardings

Florence Harding, much as she probably had once enjoyed a snort of something, was a sick woman with a chronic, life-threatening kidney ailment. Alcohol was verboten, and not an option. Nevertheless, back in Ohio, at the Hardings’ regular poker games, she was a player of poker (and politics) – and the sociable bartender for the gang. 

As President, formal WH occasions were dry. But the upstairs private quarters were not. And when their bootleg-happy buddies came for a private visit, medicinal something-or-other was readily available. 

The Coolidges

The Coolidges

Republican Calvin Coolidge and his wife were descendants of New England puritan stock – sort of. As a local politician, Coolidge regularly stopped in where the men gathered, had a beer, smoked a cigar, and shook hands. His personal thrifty “entertaining” was more coffee and cake, but a bottle of whiskey was generally available – if someone wanted a drink. Refills were frowned upon – and he counted them.

As Massachusetts Governor, the Coolidges were invited everywhere – and went. And likely had a sip of something or other. But in the White House, they played by the new rules. But he was not in favor of Prohibition. He believed that it is a bad law if it makes law-abiding citizens disrespect the law, which was exactly what was happening. And it led to speakeasies, bootlegging, gang wars, and various other mayhem. 

Tools of mayhem.

The Hoovers

Herbert and Lou Henry Hoover had spent most of their married life abroad. He had become a wealthy mining engineer, mixed in high-level society, and while neither were heavy imbibers, they kept a well-stocked bar for their numerous luncheons and dinners. 

The Hoovers

An unusually well-balanced couple, Hoover did mention that in forty year of marriage, their only real argument concerned Prohibition. As President, he was obliged to set the example and Mrs. H. insisted that they support the “Noble Experiment,” which was fine enough in the White House. But when she also insisted that he dispose of a cellar filled with excellent and expensive fine wines in their California home, he rebelled.

She won the argument. He obeyed. He didn’t like it. And he didn’t like the law either. But he said he was obliged to to live with Mrs. Hoover. 

The F.D. Roosevelts

The Roosevelts

There was no question about where Franklin Delano Roosevelt stood on Prohibition. He was a “wet.” He had enjoyed a pre-dinner cocktail from the time he was old enough to have one. His wife Eleanor was more timid on the subject, especially since her beloved father was an alcoholic and died at 34, from its complications. 

Happily for the FDRs, Prohibition was repealed (the only Constitutional Amendment with that distinction) shortly after he became President. And “happy hour” prior to dinner was the relaxing high point of many a day for FDR and close associates, and that included Eleanor. At least for one drink. 

Sources:

Stoddard, Henry L. – As I Knew Them – Harper & Brothers, 1927

Sullivan, Mark – Our Times: The Twenties – Charles Scribners’ Sons, 1935

https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/march-22/fdr-legalizes-sale-of-beer-and-wine

https://www.whitehousehistory.org/bios/woodrow-wilson

https://millercenter.org/president/harding/life-before-the-presidency

Posted in A POTUS-FLOTUS Blog, Calvin Coolidge, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Herbert Hoover, Warren G. Harding, Woodrow Wilson | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment